Was your classmate’s reasoning articulate and logical? Were the facts correct?, business and finance homework help

Hello, please create a discussion response for the attached postings. The responses should be written as if you were reviewing his or her posting in an academic journal. Your discussion response should therefore answer the following questions as applicable:

1. 1. Was your classmate’s reasoning articulate and logical? Were the facts correct?
   2. Was the interpretation your classmate provided reasonable and consistent with experts in the field? Did your classmate defend the choices effectively?
2. The focus for your critical analysis is not whether or not you agree with your classmate and is not to be a recap of all that was shared by your classmate, but is to academically critique how well his or her position was presented with points and counterpoints.
3. Each response should be 200 words in length and include, at a minimum, three sources properly cited and referenced: Block, P. (2011. Flawless consulting: A guide to getting your expertise used (3rd ed.). & HRO: Cloudy With a Chance of Consulting article http://www.workforce.com/2016/03/30/hro-cloudy-wit…